The University of Pittsburgh recently published a report addressing antisemitism on campus, but has faced criticism for failing to consult with its Jewish student population during the research process. Despite a working group composed of Jewish individuals compiling the report, the university’s 1,400 Jewish students were not approached for testimony or input. This omission has raised concerns about the report’s accuracy and comprehensiveness in reflecting the experiences of those directly affected by antisemitism at the University of Pittsburgh. A writer connected to the report defended the process, stating the group involved was “a very diverse group” of people. Critics argue that genuine diversity requires including the voices of those most impacted, which in this case, were the Jewish students at the University of Pittsburgh. The lack of student consultation casts a shadow over the report’s findings and recommendations, prompting questions about the university’s commitment to addressing antisemitism effectively.