Recent tensions between the US and India, stemming from a fatal incident in the Gulf of Oman, are jeopardizing the cohesion of the Quad alliance—comprising the US, Japan, Australia, and India. The incident, resulting in the deaths of Indian sailors, has significantly strained US-India relations, potentially hindering the Quad’s strategic goals. A key objective of the Quad is to challenge China’s control over the supply of critical minerals, essential for various technologies and industries. The alliance aimed to diversify mineral sources and reduce dependence on China’s dominance in the sector. However, the current rift raises questions about the Quad’s ability to effectively pursue this agenda. Despite these challenges, factors may emerge to counteract the disunity and maintain the Quad’s momentum.