A recent article in *La Silla Vacía* addresses a perceived false dilemma within journalism: whether its public service and oversight functions necessitate political activism. The piece argues that while good journalism inherently involves civic engagement and accountability, it should not equate to partisan allegiance. It emphasizes the importance of maintaining neutrality despite a commitment to public scrutiny. The author contends that crossing the line into political militancy compromises the profession’s core principles. This distinction is crucial for preserving public trust and ensuring effective oversight of power. The article suggests a nuanced understanding of journalism’s role, balancing active civic duty with impartial reporting. Ultimately, the piece advocates for a watchdog role, not a political one.