A group of academics is demanding an independent investigation into the appointment of Jason Arday to a professorship at Cambridge University. Concerns center on the speed and circumstances surrounding his appointment, particularly given his limited published research. Professor Priyamvada Gopal, a member of the group, argues that Cambridge is not equipped to objectively evaluate the situation and should not be allowed to self-regulate. The academics believe an external review is essential to uphold the university’s reputation and ensure fairness. They question the established procedures and want transparency in the selection process. The call for an inquiry aims to address potential issues relating to equity, diversity, and inclusion alongside academic standards. This situation sparks broader debate on the criteria for professorial appointments within elite institutions.