Despite decades since the 1956 Women’s Day march, South Africa continues to grapple with pervasive gender-based violence. Current statistics and allocated budgets offer little insight into the effectiveness of state interventions aimed at addressing this crisis. A critical gap exists between reported numbers and demonstrable improvements in the safety and well-being of women. The current approach appears to lack a clear evaluation of whether governmental programs are actually “fit for purpose.” Simply tracking statistics does not translate to eradicating violence or providing support for victims. A more nuanced assessment is needed to determine what strategies genuinely combat gender-based violence in the country. Without effective evaluation, South Africa risks perpetuating ineffective measures despite acknowledging the urgent need for change.