Katie Simpson, a young showjumper, was found unconscious and not breathing at the home of Jonathan Creswell, who was later charged with her murder. Initial investigations accepted Creswell’s account of discovering her, but the case became increasingly complex. Creswell died by suicide before the trial’s conclusion, leaving many aspects of Simpson’s death unexplained. Journalist Nicola Tallant, author of a book detailing the case, believes the full story remains untold, despite extensive coverage in documentaries, podcasts, and official reports. A Police Ombudsman’s report and an independent case review have also been conducted. The case continues to raise concerns and questions within the showjumping community and beyond, prompting ongoing scrutiny of the circumstances surrounding Simpson’s death.