Vladimir Putin celebrated his birthday in Moscow with former German Chancellor Gerhard Schröder as his guest. Schröder’s presence in Moscow has sparked controversy in Germany, given his ongoing connections to Russia. This visit follows Schröder taking on a new position with a Russian supermarket chain, further fueling criticism. Critics question the appropriateness of a former head of government maintaining close ties with Putin, particularly amid ongoing geopolitical tensions. The meeting underscores the complex relationship between Germany and Russia. Schröder has faced increasing pressure to distance himself from the Kremlin, but has so far resisted widespread calls to do so. This birthday meeting represents a continued display of that relationship.