Historian Jean-Pierre Robin draws parallels between the perceived failures of President Macron’s ten years in office and France’s defeat in 1940. Robin argues that enduring French societal issues, previously identified by historian Marc Bloch, contributed to both events. These issues include a strong resistance to reforms and a perceived lack of work ethic. The article frames Macron’s recent political setbacks as stemming from these deeply rooted national characteristics. Robin suggests a continuity of problems hindering France’s progress, spanning decades and impacting its ability to adapt and succeed. The commentary positions the end of Macron’s decade as a moment for reflection on these persistent national failings, rather than solely attributing blame to political leadership. It implies a systemic issue within French society that requires addressing beyond policy changes.