Katherina Reiche, a prominent figure in German energy policy, has become a frequent target of criticism. The article questions whether the intense focus on criticizing Reiche is justified, despite numerous arguments against her policies. It suggests that Germany’s “Energiewende,” or energy transition—the shift towards renewable energy sources—will likely continue regardless of her continued involvement. The piece frames Reiche as a central, yet controversial, figure in the debate surrounding Germany’s energy future. It implies a discussion about the nature of political critique and whether personal attacks overshadow substantive policy debate. Ultimately, the column posits that the energy transition’s momentum is independent of any single individual.