Former Supreme Court Associate Justice Antonio Carpio has proposed alternative strategies for resupplying Philippine troops stationed at the BRP Sierra Madre, currently grounded at the Ayungin Shoal. These suggestions come in response to the Department of Foreign Affairs’ defense of the “Ayungin Deal,” which Carpio believes relies too heavily on China’s approval. He criticized the current approach, implying it concedes too much authority to China regarding access to the vessel. Carpio’s insights offer potential avenues for the Philippines to maintain its presence in the disputed waters without being subjected to potentially restrictive terms. He believes alternatives exist that prioritize Philippine sovereignty and logistical independence. The former justice did not detail his specific suggestions in this initial statement, promising further elaboration. This debate highlights ongoing tensions and the search for effective strategies in the South China Sea.