Spanish writer Irene Vallejo highlights a long-standing, controversial theory regarding the authorship of Homer’s *The Odyssey*. The theory, originally proposed by Samuel Butler, challenges the traditional attribution to the male poet Homer. Vallejo revisits this idea, questioning whether a woman might have been the true author of the epic poem. This provocative hypothesis continues to fuel debate and re-examine perceptions of classical literature. It forces readers to consider the influence of gender on authorship and narrative. The discussion encourages a fresh look at the ancient world and the possibilities surrounding its greatest works. Vallejo’s article reignites the conversation about who *really* penned this foundational text.