Over 215 Indian academicians have issued a statement strongly criticizing Congress leader Priyanka Gandhi’s remarks concerning the appointment of Professor V. Kamakoti as the director of IIT-Madras. The academics argue Gandhi’s comments, perceived as mocking Kamakoti’s background, were a disrespectful substitute for substantive engagement with important issues of academic governance. They contend that Kamakoti’s appointment was made through due process and is not grounds for ridicule. The statement expresses concern that such remarks undermine the dignity of technical institutions and discourage qualified individuals from taking on leadership roles. It further emphasizes the need for respectful discourse around appointments and policies within academic circles, rejecting personal attacks as a legitimate form of critique. The signatories believe Gandhi’s approach sets a dangerous precedent for political interference in academic autonomy. They urge a focus on constructive criticism rather than dismissive commentary.