A panel tasked with evaluating a potential merger of three Western Australian universities – Curtin, Murdoch and the University of Western Australia – is facing scrutiny due to the strong affiliations of its members. Most panelists have existing ties to a single university, raising concerns about potential bias in the forthcoming business case. The panel is responsible for presenting a plan to consolidate Curtin, Murdoch and the University of Western Australia into one “mega-university.” Details regarding the nature and extent of these connections are emerging, fueling debate over the fairness and objectivity of the merger evaluation process. Critics argue that the dominance of representatives from one institution could influence recommendations, potentially disadvantaging the other universities involved. The business case will be crucial in determining the future of higher education in Western Australia. Further investigation is expected to reveal the full extent of the connections and their potential impact.