A new poll reveals a disturbing trend: nearly one-third of young Americans harbor views identifying Jews as a threat to society. The Blue Square survey also found that almost half of all US respondents recognize antisemitism as a “major problem.” However, a significant majority believe Jewish communities should address antisemitism independently, without broader societal intervention. This finding highlights a concerning disconnect between acknowledging the existence of antisemitism and believing Jewish people require assistance in combating it. The poll underscores rising anxieties regarding Jewish safety and acceptance in the United States, particularly amongst younger generations. While awareness of antisemitism is growing, the inclination to leave its resolution solely to Jews raises questions about societal responsibility and allyship. Further research is needed to understand the root causes of these perceptions and develop effective strategies for fostering inclusivity and combating prejudice.