A recent editorial in *Le Figaro Magazine* criticizes the state of France’s criminal justice system, arguing it poses a threat to democratic stability. The article points to significant failings and unacceptable dysfunctions within the penal chain – encompassing investigation, prosecution, and sentencing. These issues, acknowledged by the current Minister of Justice, are eroding public trust. The editorial suggests a lack of accountability among magistrates, but crucially implicates leadership as setting a poor example. It implies that systemic problems originate from the top down, rather than solely with individual judges. The piece calls for serious reform to address these weaknesses and restore faith in the rule of law. Ultimately, the author contends that a properly functioning justice system is vital for a healthy democracy.