The question of whether celebrating the birthday of Prophet Muhammad (Maulid Nabi SAW) is permissible under Islamic law is a subject of ongoing debate among scholars. The article explores historical viewpoints from Islamic authorities on this practice. It seeks to clarify the legal standing of commemorating the Prophet’s birth. The text suggests a detailed examination of opinions from past *ulama* (scholars) will be presented. This aims to provide insight into differing interpretations within the Islamic faith. Ultimately, the article offers a deeper understanding of the discussion concerning the permissibility of this widely observed tradition. The piece promises to lay out the scholarly grounding for the various positions.