Journalist Christine Goguet examines the disconnect between artistic or intellectual achievement and personal character in her new essay, *Great Men and the Devil*. The work investigates the darker aspects of approximately fifteen prominent figures, challenging the notion that talent equates to virtue. Goguet’s research prompts a critical question: should we separate an individual’s creations from their personal conduct? The essay is described as both demanding and provocative in its exploration of this complex issue. It suggests that genius or fame does not necessarily correlate with moral excellence. The book aims to reveal a less flattering side to those often held in high esteem, prompting readers to reconsider their perceptions of public figures. Goguet’s work encourages a nuanced understanding of celebrated individuals, acknowledging both their contributions and their flaws.